From the studio

Does beauty have a ‘founder’ problem?

Hailey Bieber for Rhode Beauty | Does Beauty have a founder problem.

Is it the end of founder-led beauty?

A founder can give a beauty brand something valuable: A distinctive brand world, a unique perspective, celebrity, and a face to the ‘why’.

However, the beauty industry is actively grappling with founder-led beauty brands struggling to scale and transition into financial longevity. Only 5 brands founded since 2005 have successfully crossed the $1 billion revenue mark (Fenty Beauty and The Ordinary). The market seems to have hit a ceiling where personal taste and founder influence can effortlessly spark a brand’s launch, but completely fall flat when a brand is solely built on the personal trust of its founder.

Trend-fatigue for the beauty lovers

Another aspect is that consumers are actively rejecting hyper-marketed brands that rely entirely on a name or extreme marketing claims. Buyers now place product performance (39%) and price (24%) far above founder identity (13%) according to BoF. Rather than buying into just an identity, beauty consumers are holding brands to much higher standards.

Now they expect brands to go beyond the standard beauty brand codes such as sustainably sourced ingredients…

Brands who have seen their front-facing founders step away, such as Pat McGrath, and most recently Isymaya Ffrench’s split from their namesake brands, among others like Rhode’s Hailey Bieber and Ouai’s Jen Atkin, are left with a collaboration problem.

However for most beauty brands they operate as Beauty incubators. They provide the formula, supply chain, and retail connections, while founders provide the cultural hype and creative spark.

Does beauty have a ‘founder’ problem?
Image from BoF

So can a beauty brand really survive without its front-facing founder?

Absolutely. The parting of a founder, and the success of a brand depends on whether the brands vision was built as a cult of personality or a transferable ethos. Once the founder leaves the incubator model switches from collaborative to corporate. Shifting from founder-led to ‘Purpose-Led’ or Ingredient Storytelling.

Codify the “founder” into brand Assets you can sell

Instead of relying on the founder’s physical face to tell the story, the brand must be able to translate the founder’s core philosophy into a permanent visual identity and playbook. When I work with my client we document everything from specific ways of blending textures, core cultural cues to building visual codes that are distinct only to them even down to product naming mechanics.

Transitioning from “Me” to “We”

Sell a distinct aesthetic mood or a specific subculture that tranitions the brand from founder-led to community-led.The brand’s primary marketing narrative must pivot so that the consumer, rather than the founder, becomes the main character in the brand story. Shifting social media strategies from behind-the-scenes content of the founder’s life to highlighting the diverse community of everyday users. Build a diverse global council of master makeup artists, dermatologists, or content creators.

Perhaps beauty doesn’t have a founder problem at all. Perhaps it has a brand dependency problem.

The test is the legacy of why it matters when that person is no longer in the room

This is something I examine closely in my work with founders and decision-makers.

Through brand positioning, it’s important to examine how the brand is perceived, what makes it distinctive, where its value is being communicated effectively and where its identity, positioning or customer experience may be limiting its potential.

With my years working with beauty founders the most successful founder-led brands are those that understand when to translate their vision into something collectively understood, valued and desired.


Is your brand building equity, or borrowing influence?

If you’re preparing to scale, reposition or make a significant investment in your brand, understanding where its real value lies should come before deciding what to do next.

free Download
4 Ways to go from looking like a 'side-hustler' to looking like a 'Professional' brand

Join a community of luxury-led founders who are already getting exclusive insights, case studies, and news for building a premium wellness and beauty brand.

How to go from looking like a side hustler to professional

Thank you!

It’s on the way to you.

Be sure to check you inbox for your link to your download. I hope you find it as helpful as the many others before you!

– Kate 

Thank you for your enquiry

Myself or someone from my team will be in touch shortly to respond to your enquiry.

I look forward to connecting with you.

Warmest, Kate